The following documents provide quick access to cases of public interest in Wake County. Document copies in this case may be obtained from the Civil Division of the Clerk of Court located at the Wake County Courthouse (316 Fayetteville Street, Raleigh, NC).

• Judgment
• Remedy Phase
   
• Information Regarding the Trial of Common Cause, et al. v. Lewis, et al. (18 CVS 14001) in Raleigh, NC – Information and guidelines regarding the trial in this matter, set to begin at 10:00 a.m. on Monday, July 15, 2019, at the Campbell University School of Law.
• Documents
• Administrative Orders
• Case Management and Scheduling
• Pleadings and Intervention
• Trial Exhibits
  • Intervenor Defendants
  • Legislative Defendants
• Trial Materials
• Post-Trial Submissions

Documents

The 6-digit numbers in each filename indicate the date the document was filed in the following format: YYMMDD. For example, 190711 would indicate that a document was filed on July 11, 2019.

1. 190219 Plaintiffs' First Motion to Compel w Exhibits
2. 190222 Plaintiffs' Second Motion to Compel w Exhibits
3. 190318 Legislative Defendants Opposition to Plaintiffs 1st and 2nd Motions to Compel
4. 190319 Plaintiffs Supplemental Brief re Motions
5. 190325 Order on Defendants Motion for Protective Order and Plaintiffs Motion to Compel
6. 190404 Plaintiffs Motion for Clarification Pursuant to Rule 45
7. 190411 Intervenor-Defs Resp in Opposition to Plaintiffs Motion for Clarification
8. 190411 Legislative Defendants Resp in Opposition to Plaintiffs Mtn for Clarification
9. 190412 Plaintiffs Reply on Motion for Clarification
10. 190412 Plaintiffs Supplemental Brief on MTCs with Exhibits
11. 190417 Plaintiffs Third Motion to Compel (Subpoena to North Carolina Republican Party)
12. 190426 Legislative Defendants Resp to Plaintiffs Supplemental Brief
13. 190501 Order - discovery motions
14. 190507 Legislative Defendants Motion to Compel Documents from NCDP
15. 190509 Plaintiffs Brief Supporting Third Mtn to Compel (Subpoena to NC GOP)
16. 190510 Plaintiffs Fees-Costs Affidavit (Abha Khanna)
17. 190510 Plaintiffs Fees-Costs Affidavit (Caroline P. Mackie)
18. 190510 Plaintiffs Fees-Costs Affidavit (R. Stanton Jones)
19. 190606 Plaintiffs Motion for Direction
20. 190607 Order on Attorney Fees
21. 190607 Order on Legislative Defs Mtn to Compel to Pl NCDP
22. 190607 Order on Plaintiffs 3rd Mtn to Compel to NCGOP
23. 190615 Geographic Strategies Motions and Affidavit
24. 190621 Order granting in part Legislative Defendants MTC NCDP support scores
25. 190626 Plaintiffs Opposition to Geographic Strategies Motion
26. 190628 Geographic Strategies Reply re Motion for Protective Order
27. 190708 Intervenor Defs and Legislative Defs Joint Objections to Pls Exhibits
28. 190708 Intervenor Defs Pre-Trial Brief
29. 190708 Legislative Defendants Pre-Trial Brief
30. 190708 Legislative Defendants Resp to Pls Emergency Mtn to Compel Prod of Revised Calculations from Dr. Lewis
31. 190708 Motion to Extend time to File Pretrial Stipulations
32. 190708 Plaintiffs Objections to Defendants Trial Exhibits
33. 190708 Plaintiffs Pre-Trial Brief
34. 190708 NOH (7.10.19 hearing on pending pre-trial mtns)
35. 190426 – Plaintiffs’ Supplemental Reply Brief Concerning Their First and Second Motions to Compel
36. 190429 – Legislative Defendants’ Response to Plaintiffs’ “Supplemental Reply Brief Concerning their first and second motions to Compel”
37. 190514 – Plaintiff North Carolina Democratic Party’s Opposition to Legislative Defendants’ Motion to Compel Production of Documents from N.C. Democratic Party
38. 190521– Leg Defs Reply in Support of Motion to Compel
39. 190521 – Revised Exhibit D to Legislative Defendants Reply in Support of Motion to Compel
40. 190617 – Legislative Defendants’ Response to Plaintiffs’ Motion for Direction
41. 190621 – Legislative Defendants’ Motion in Limine re: Excluding Hofeller Files
42. 190621 – Legislative Defendants’ Motion in Limine re: Excluding Plaintiffs’ Expert Testimony
43. 190621 – Exhibits to Plaintiffs’ Motion in Limine re: Admitting Certain Hofeller Files
44. 190621 – Plaintiffs’ Motion in Limine re: Legislative Defendants and Intervenor Defendants’ Expert Testimony
45. 190627 – Plaintiffs Reply Brief re: Motion for Direction
46. 190701 – Intervenor Defendants’ Response in Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion in Limine re: Excluding Expert Testimony
47. 190701 – Legislative Defendants’ Response to Plaintiffs’ Motion in Limine to Preclude Defendants from introducing expert testimony not disclosed in Expert Reports
48. 190701 – Plaintiffs’ Opposition to Legislative Defendants’ Motion in Limine re: expert testimony on legal conclusions
49. 190701 – Plaintiffs’ Opposition to Motion in Limine re: Excluding Hofeller Files
50. 190705 – Plaintiffs’ Emergency Motion to Compel Legislative Defendants to Produce Revised Calculations of Dr. Jeffrey Lewis
51. 190712 – Order on Geographic Strategies Motion re: Hofeller Files
52. 190712 – Order on Geographic Strategies Motion to Appear
53. 190712 – Order on Motions in Limine re Hofeller Files
54. 190712 – Order on Plaintiffs Motion for Direction
55. 190717 – Order on Geographic Strategies Motion for Clarification
56. 190717 – Order on Outstanding Pre-Trial Motions

Administrative Orders

57. 181128 Chief Justice Order
58. 181214 Pro Hac Vice Motion
59. 190122 Pro Hac Vice Motion
60. 190423 Notice of Hearing
61. 190503 Plaintiffs Pro Hac Vice Motion
62. 190503 Pro Hac Vice Order
63. 190507 Legislative Defendants Pro Hac Vice Motion
64. 190508 Pro Hac Vice Order
65. 190514 Pro Hac Vice Order (McKnight)
66. 190514 Pro Hac Vice Order (Scully)
67. 190522 Notice of Hearing
68. 190528 Legislative Defendants Pro Hac Vice Motion Patrick T. Lewis
69. 190528 Legislative Defendants Pro Hac Vice Motion Robert J. Tucker
70. 190529 Pro Hac Vice Order Lewis
71. 190529 Pro Hac Vice Order Tucker
72. 190702 NOH 7.2.19 hearing re Hofeller files

Case Management and Scheduling

73. 181120 Motion for Expedited Discovery & scheduling order
74. 181212 Memo in support of Motion for Expedited Discovery
75. 190119 Letter from Plaintiff counsel
76. 190120 Defendants’ statement of position on scheduling
77. 190120 Letter from Defense counsel
78. 190129 Defendants’ Position on scheduling
79. 190129 Plaintiffs' Proposed Scheduling Order
80. 190129 State Defendants’ position on Scheduling Order
81. 190201 Scheduling Order
82. 190205 Legislative Defendants Motion for a Protective Order re depositions
83. 190215 Stipulated Proposed Case Management Order
84. 190311 Plaintiffs' Response to Legislative Defendants Motion for PO
85. 190313 Case Management Order
86. 190321 Amended Case Management Order
87. 190405 Consent Protective Order
88. 190422 Legislative Defendants Mtn to Amend Case Management Order
89. 190425 Plaintiffs Opposition to Legislative Defs Mtn to Amend CMO
90. 190509 Plaintiffs Motion for Extension of Time for Rebuttal Expert Reports
91. 190514 Plaintiffs Reply on Extension Request
92. 190522 Amended Case Management Order

Pleadings and Intervention

93. 181113 Complaint
94. 181207 Amended Complaint
95. 190102 Federal Court Order to Remand
96. 190129 Motion to Intervene
97. 190204 Opposition to Motion to Intervene
98. 190207 State Board Members Notice to Join Answer
99. 190213 Voluntary Dismissal of State Defendants
100. 190215 Legislative Defendants Answer
101. 190226 Order granting intervention
102. State Def's Answer to Amended Complaint

Trial Materials

103. 190621 - Int Defs Mtn in Limine re Excluding Reid Dimissed Charges
104. 190621 - Int Defs Mtn in Limine re Excluding Reid Social Media Evidence
105. 190621 - Pls Mtn in Limine re Admitting certain Hofeller files
106. 190621 - Pls Mtn in Limine re Int Defs and Live Testimony
107. 190621 - Pls Mtn in Limine re Leg Defs and Sword and Shield Doctrine
108. 190621 - Pls Mtn in Limine re Leg Defs and Voting Rights Act
109. 190701 - Int Defs Resp in Opp to Pls MIL to Exclude Live Testimony
110. 190701 - Leg Def Opp to Mtn in Limine re Admitting certain Hofeller files
111. 190701 - Leg Defs Opp to Pls MIL to Preclude VRA Evidence
112. 190701 - Leg Defs Resp to Pls MIL to Preclude Leg Defs re Sword and Shield doctrine
113. 190701 - Pls Opp to Int Defs MIL to Exclude Social Media Evidence
114. 190701 - Pls Resp to Int Defs MIL to Exclude Evidence of Dismissed Criminal Charges

Trial Exhibits

Plaintiff

115. EX0590
116. EX0591
117. EX0597
118. EX0601
119. EX0602
120. EX0603
121. EX0606
122. EX0607
123. EX0631
124. EX0632
125. EX0633
126. EX0634
127. EX0644
128. EX0757
129. EX0002
130. EX0003
131. EX0004
132. EX0005
133. EX0007
134. EX0008
135. EX0009
136. EX0010
137. EX0011
138. EX0012
139. EX0013
140. EX0014
141. EX0015
142. EX0016
143. EX0017
144. EX0018
145. EX0020
146. EX0021
147. EX0022
148. EX0023
149. EX0026
150. EX0027
151. EX0028
152. EX0029
153. EX0030
154. EX0031
155. EX0032
156. EX0033
157. EX0034
158. EX0035
159. EX0036
160. EX0037
161. EX0039
162. EX0040
163. EX0041
164. EX0042
165. EX0045
166. EX0046
167. EX0047
168. EX0048
169. EX0049
170. EX0050
171. EX0051
172. EX0052
173. EX0053
174. EX0054
175. EX0055
176. EX0056
177. EX0057
178. EX0058
179. EX0059
180. EX0060
181. EX0061
182. EX0062
183. EX0063
184. EX0064
185. EX0065
186. EX0066
187. EX0067
188. EX0068
189. EX0069
190. EX0070
191. EX0071
192. EX0072
193. EX0073
194. EX0074
195. EX0075
196. EX0076
197. EX0081
198. EX0086
199. EX0090
200. EX0094
201. EX0095
202. EX0096
203. EX0097
204. EX0098
205. EX0099
206. EX0100
207. EX0101
208. EX0102
209. EX0103
210. EX0104
211. EX0105
212. EX0106
213. EX0107
214. EX0117
215. EX0118
216. EX0119
217. EX0121
218. EX0124
219. EX0125
220. EX0126
221. EX0127
222. EX0128
223. EX0129
224. EX0131
225. EX0132
226. EX0133
227. EX0140
228. EX0141
229. EX0142
230. EX0143
231. EX0144
232. EX0145
233. EX0146
234. EX0147
235. EX0148
236. EX0149
237. EX0150
238. EX0151
239. EX0152
240. EX0153
241. EX0154
242. EX0165
243. EX0166
244. EX0167
245. EX0168
246. EX0169
247. EX0170
248. EX0171
249. EX0172
250. EX0173
251. EX0218
252. EX0219
253. EX0220
254. EX0222
255. EX0223
256. EX0225
257. EX0226
258. EX0227
259. EX0228
260. EX0234
261. EX0236
262. EX0238
263. EX0239
264. EX0241
265. EX0244
266. EX0246
267. EX0248
268. EX0569
269. EX0570
270. EX0571
271. EX0572
272. EX0586
273. EX0594
274. EX0606
275. EX0254
276. EX0255
277. EX0256
278. EX0257
279. EX0258
280. EX0259
281. EX0260
282. EX0261
283. EX0262
284. EX0263
285. EX0264
286. EX0265
287. EX0266
288. EX0267
289. EX0268
290. EX0269
291. EX0270
292. EX0271
293. EX0272
294. EX0273
295. EX0274
296. EX0275
297. EX0276
298. EX0277
299. EX0278
300. EX0279
301. EX0280
302. EX0281
303. EX0282
304. EX0283
305. EX0284
306. EX0285
307. EX0286
308. EX0287
309. EX0288
310. EX0289
311. EX0290
312. EX0291
313. EX0292
314. EX0293
315. EX0294
316. EX0295
317. EX0296
318. EX0297
319. EX0298
320. EX0299
321. EX0300
322. EX0301
323. EX0302
324. EX0303
325. EX0304
326. EX0305
327. EX0306
328. EX0307
329. EX0308
330. EX0309
331. EX0310
332. EX0311
333. EX0312
334. EX0313
335. EX0314
336. EX0315
337. EX0316
338. EX0317
339. EX0318
340. EX0319
341. EX0320
342. EX0321
343. EX0322
344. EX0323
345. EX0324
346. EX0325
347. EX0326
348. EX0327
349. EX0328
350. EX0330
351. EX0331
352. EX0332
353. EX0333
354. EX0334
355. EX0335
356. EX0336
357. EX0337
358. EX0338
359. EX0339
360. EX0340
361. EX0341
362. EX0342
363. EX0343
364. EX0344
365. EX0345
366. EX0346
367. EX0347
368. EX0348
369. EX0349
370. EX0350
371. EX0351
372. EX0352
373. EX0353
374. EX0354
375. EX0355
376. EX0356
377. EX0360
378. EX0361
379. EX0362
380. EX0363
381. EX0364
382. EX0365
383. EX0366
384. EX0367
385. EX0368
386. EX0369
387. EX0370
388. EX0371
389. EX0372
390. EX0373
391. EX0374
392. EX0375
393. EX0376
394. EX0377
395. EX0378
396. EX0379
397. EX0380
398. EX0381
399. EX0382
400. EX0383
401. EX0384
402. EX0385
403. EX0386
404. EX0387
405. EX0388
406. EX0389
407. EX0390
408. EX0391
409. EX0392
410. EX0393
411. EX0394
412. EX0395
413. EX0396
414. EX0397
415. EX0398
416. EX0399
417. EX0400
418. EX0401
419. EX0402
420. EX0403
421. EX0404
422. EX0405
423. EX0406
424. EX0407
425. EX0408
426. EX0409
427. EX0410
428. EX0411
429. EX0412
430. EX0413
431. EX0414
432. EX0415
433. EX0416
434. EX0417
435. EX0418
436. EX0422
437. EX0423
438. EX0424
439. EX0425
440. EX0426
441. EX0427
442. EX0428
443. EX0429
444. EX0430
445. EX0431
446. EX0432
447. EX0433
448. EX0434
449. EX0435
450. EX0436
451. EX0437
452. EX0438
453. EX0439
454. EX0440
455. EX0441
456. EX0442
457. EX0443
458. EX0444
459. EX0445
460. EX0446
461. EX0447
462. EX0448
463. EX0449
464. EX0450
465. EX0451
466. EX0452
467. EX0453
468. EX0454
469. EX0455
470. EX0456
471. EX0457
472. EX0458
473. EX0459
474. EX0460
475. EX0461
476. EX0462
477. EX0463
478. EX0464
479. EX0465
480. EX0466
481. EX0467
482. EX0468
483. EX0471
484. EX0472
485. EX0473
486. EX0474
487. EX0475
488. EX0476
489. EX0477
490. EX0478
491. EX0479
492. EX0480
493. EX0481
494. EX0482
495. EX0483
496. EX0484
497. EX0485
498. EX0486
499. EX0488
500. EX0489
501. EX0490
502. EX0491
503. EX0493
504. EX0494
505. EX0495
506. EX0496
507. EX0497
508. EX0562
509. EX0563
510. EX0564
511. EX0565
512. EX0566
513. EX0646
514. EX0647 - pages 1-120 | pages 121-240
515. EX0001

Intervenor Defendants

• ID Ex. 1 - Barber Figure 1 Historical Partisan Composition of NC Legislature (Amended)
• ID Ex. 2 - Barber Figure 2-1 Simple Example of Districting and Voter Geographic Distributions Hypothetical State 1
• ID Ex. 3 - Barber Figure 2-2 Simple Example of Districting and Voter Geographic Distributions Hypothetical State 2
• ID Ex. 4 - Barber Figure 2-3 Simple Example of Districting and Voter Geographic Distributions Hypothetical State 3
• ID Ex. 5 - Barber Figure 3-1 Statewide Vote to Legislature Seats Relationship (Amended)
• ID Ex. 6 - Barber Figure 3-2 Statewide Vote to Legislature Seats Relationship (Zoomed In) (Amended)
• ID Ex. 7 - Barber Figure 4 Population Density of VTDs in North Carolina
• ID Ex. 8 - Barber Figure 5 Population Density of Counties in North Carolina
• ID Ex. 9 - Barber Figure 6 Partisan Lean of VTDs in North Carolina
• ID Ex. 10 - Barber Figure 7 Partisan Lean of Counties in North Carolina
• ID Ex. 11 - Barber Figure 8-1 Relationship Between Population Density and Democratic Vote for VTDs
• ID Ex. 12 - Barber Figure 8-2 Relationship Between Population Density and Democratic Vote for Counties
• ID Ex. 14 - Barber Table 1 Hypothetical Preferences of Voters and Votes Cast by State Legislator
• ID Ex. 15 - Barber Table 2 Elections Used in Partisan Index
• ID Ex. 16 - Barber Table 3 Regression Model of Population Density and Democratic Support
• ID Ex. 23 - Barber Deposition Exhibit 8 - Demonstrative Exhibits (Corrected Amended)
• ID Ex. 24 - Alamance County 2018 Senate Districts
• ID Ex. 25 - Alamance County 2018 House Districts
• ID Ex. 61 - C. Elmore Voter Lookup Record
• ID Ex. 62 - C. Groce Voter Lookup Record
• ID Ex. 63 - R. Reid Voter Lookup Record
• ID Ex. 64 - B. York Voter Lookup Record
• ID Ex. 65 - Affidavit of Aubrey Otis Woodard
• ID Ex. 66 - Affidavit of Rev. Cathy Ann Williams Fanslau
• ID Ex. 67 - Affidavit of Adrain Arnett (Amended)
• ID Ex. 98 - Dr. Michael Barber Curriculum Vitae
• ID Ex. 99 - Dr. Michael Barber Expert Report
• ID Ex. 100 - Affidavit of Bettie Carolyn Elmore
• ID Ex. 101 - Affidavit of Reginald Delano Reid

Legislative Defendants

• LDTX001
• LDTX002
• LDTX003
• LDTX004
• LDTX005
• LDTX006
• LDTX007
• LDTX008
• LDTX009
• LDTX010
• LDTX011
• LDTX012
• LDTX013
• LDTX014
• LDTX015
• LDTX016
• LDTX017
• LDTX018
• LDTX019
• LDTX026
• LDTX027
• LDTX028
• LDTX029
• LDTX030
• LDTX031
• LDTX032
• LDTX033
• LDTX034
• LDTX035
• LDTX036
• LDTX037
• LDTX038
• LDTX039
• LDTX040
• LDTX041
• LDTX042
• LDTX043
• LDTX044
• LDTX045
• LDTX046
• LDTX047
• LDTX048
• LDTX049
• LDTX050
• LDTX051
• LDTX053
• LDTX054
• LDTX055
• LDTX061
• LDTX062
• LDTX063
• LDTX064
• LDTX065
• LDTX066
• LDTX067
• LDTX068
• LDTX069
• LDTX070
• LDTX072
• LDTX073
• LDTX074
• LDTX075
• LDTX076
• LDTX077
• LDTX078
• LDTX079
• LDTX080
• LDTX081
• LDTX082
• LDTX085
• LDTX086
• LDTX087
• LDTX088
• LDTX091
• LDTX092
• LDTX093
• LDTX094
• LDTX095
• LDTX096
• LDTX097
• LDTX098
• LDTX099
• LDTX100
• LDTX101
• LDTX102
• LDTX103
• LDTX104
• LDTX105
• LDTX106
• LDTX107
• LDTX108
• LDTX109
• LDTX110
• LDTX111
• LDTX114
• LDTX115
• LDTX116
• LDTX117
• LDTX118
• LDTX119
• LDTX120
• LDTX121
• LDTX122
• LDTX123
• LDTX124
• LDTX125
• LDTX126
• LDTX127
• LDTX128
• LDTX129
• LDTX130
• LDTX131
• LDTX132
• LDTX133
• LDTX134
• LDTX135
• LDTX136
• LDTX137
• LDTX138
• LDTX139
• LDTX140
• LDTX145
• LDTX146
• LDTX147
• LDTX150
• LDTX154
• LDTX155
• LDTX160
• LDTX161
• LDTX163
• LDTX164
• LDTX165
• LDTX166
• LDTX175
• LDTX179
• LDTX180
• LDTX183
• LDTX184
• LDTX186
• LDTX190
• LDTX191
• LDTX198
• LDTX220
• LDTX221
• LDTX230
• LDTX239
• LDTX240
• LDTX241
• LDTX246
• LDTX259
• LDTX260
• LDTX263
• LDTX264
• LDTX265
• LDTX282
• LDTX283
• LDTX284
• LDTX285
• LDTX286
• LDTX287
• LDTX288
• LDTX289
• LDTX290
• LDTX291
• LDTX292
• LDTX294
• LDTX295
• LDTX297
• LDTX298
• LDTX299
• LDTX300
• LDTX301
• LDTX302
• LDTX303
• LDTX304
• LDTX305
• LDTX306
• LDTX307
• LDTX308
• LDTX309
• LDTX310
• LDTX311
• LDTX312
• LDTX313
• LDTX314
• LDTX315
• LDTX316
• LDTX317
• LDTX318
• LDTX319
• LDTX320
• LDTX321
• LDTX322
• LDTX323
• LDTX324
• LDTX325
• LDTX326
• LDTX327
• LDTX328

Post-Trial Submissions

516. 190807 - Intervenor Defendants' Post-Trial Brief
517. 190807 - Legislative and Intervenor Defendants' Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
518. 190807 - Legislative Defendants' Post-Trial Brief
519. 190807 - Plaintiffs' Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
520. 190807 - Former Governors Motion and Amicus Brief
521. 190807 - Governor Cooper and AG Stein Motion and Amicus Brief

Remedy Phase

• 190913 - Order
• 190917 - Order requesting timeline from SBOE